Bay Street Pharmacy was established in 1984 by pharmacist/owners Joe Tolle, Jr. and Frank J. Sherako. Joe also owned and operated Sebastian River Drugs in Sebastian from 1972 to 1992. Theresa Tolle, daughter-in-law of Joe, joined Bay Street Pharmacy in 1997 and became a partner in 1999. Joe retired in 2001 and Frank retired in 2005. Theresa and her husband, Joe Tolle, III, remain owners of Bay Street Pharmacy today and are proud of it's history and to continue the family tradition of serving the greater Sebastian area and fulfilling their motto, "where caring people care for you".