Find a business

        (330) 343-1188Call
        Add Website
        Map & DirectionsDirections145 2nd St NWNew Philadelphia, OH 44663Write a ReviewWrite Review

        Menu

        Pizza
        • Cheese
          $7.80
        • Meat & Cheese
          $8.30
        • Cheese & Green Peppers
          $8.10
        Pizza Subs
        • Cheese
          $2.45
        • Meat & Cheese
          $2.65
        • Meat, Cheese, Gr Pepper
          $2.80
        Meatball Subs
        • Plain (no cheese)
          $3.80
        • Splash (with cheese)
          $4.10
        View Full Menu
        Provided by
        Partner Logo

        Reviews

        Hi there!
        Rate this business!
        What do you rate this business?First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
        Click to Rate
        BG
        Bob G.

        12/19/2019

        Overall
        Atmosphere
        Food
        Service

        have lived in New Phila for 65 years, by far Mary Zifer is the best of the best, very reasonable prices excellent service

        Helpful(0)Flag
        CH
        Cindy H.

        10/16/2016

        Overall
        Food
        Service

        Girl on the phone seemed like she didn't want to be bothered with my order ... when we got our pizza it was cold and not baked they just put the toppings on raw and that's it!! Called in and she said we are very busy.. I guess they are to busy to care very sad cause we drive 20 miles for there pizza! Not again!!

        Helpful(0)Flag

        Details

        Phone: (330) 343-1188

        Address: 145 2nd St NW, New Philadelphia, OH 44663

        More Info

        Payment method
        cash only
        Price Range
        $$
        AKA

        Mary Zifer's Pizza in New Philly

        Zifer's Mary Pizza Shop

        Categories
        Pizza, Italian Restaurants, Restaurants
        Other Information

        Parking: Lot, Private

        Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

        Cuisines: Pizza, Italian, Continental, European

        Price Range : Average

        People Also Viewed

        View similar Pizza
        Suggest an Edit